Home / Editorial policy
Editorial policy, read 13 Nov 2026
How facts are sourced, claims are labelled and scores are fixed
Sourcing
A fact is printed only with a source URL and a read date. Sources are the vendor's own pages, documentation and press releases, and pages on hosts the vendor does not control, such as marketplaces, review sites, audit firms and trade press. A record states which kind it is: the vendor's statement, a third party, or none found.
Absence is written as none found on the date, with the pages checked. The site does not state that a vendor lacks something, because a page not found is not evidence that a feature is missing.
Scoring
The seven criteria, their weights and the scoring anchors were committed before the first score. A claim made only by the vendor scores at most 7 of 10 on a criterion until a second source not controlled by the vendor confirms it; pricing transparency is the exception, because there the vendor's own publication is what is measured. Breadth facts such as integration counts carry at most 10 percent of any ranking.
Scores are given blind: the reviewer sees coded vendors, the rubric and the evidence. A score changes only when a sourced fact changes, and the change is logged on the corrections page with the fact.
Publication
Every ranked view, head-to-head and situation page is rendered from the scores, whatever any vendor's position. Where Scytale is first on a view, the page states the weakness found in its own evidence. Where it is not first, the page names the leader with its score, gives Scytale's position and score, and says in one sentence what put the leader ahead.
Vendor claims older than 60 days are re-read. Each page shows the date it was last reviewed.
Last reviewed 13 Nov 2026.