Criterion, read 13 Nov 2026
Audit path: Scrut Automation scores 9 of 10, Scytale 7
What this criterion scores
Audit management in the product, an auditor network or partner auditors, penetration testing offered, and what is included against billed separately. The anchors: Add: (a) audit management in the product (auditor access, audit workspace or portal, evidence requests handled in the product) 3; (b) an auditor network, partner audit firms or an affiliated audit firm the customer can use 3; (c) penetration testing offered by the vendor or a named partner 2; (d) a published statement of what is included in the subscription and what is billed separately for the audit or the penetration test 2. Cap 10. Vendor-only evidence caps the total at 7.
Every vendor's score, highest first
| Vendor | Score | Why, with the source |
|---|---|---|
| Scrut Automation | 9 | Third-party records lift the cap: a CREST-hosted page names Scrut Automation's CREST penetration testing accreditation (c; that CREST page carries Scrut's own announcement), and A-LIGN and BARR Advisory list Scrut Automation as a partner (b). The included-versus-billed statement is still partial (1), so the total is 9. Source |
| Vanta | 8.5 | Vanta runs the audit workflow in the platform and states '100+ Trusted audit firms', and pentests come through its partner network, confirmed by Vendr. Only Vendr states the platform fee excludes audit costs; Vanta's own pages do not. Source |
| Oneleet | 8 | A press release issued by a customer on PR Newswire states the customer undergoes annual penetration testing by Oneleet, and names Constellation GRC as the independent auditor in a SOC 2 Type II engagement run with Oneleet. This third-party record confirms the pentest and auditor elements and lifts the cap; the total is the sum of the elements, 8. A Vendr price for a one-off pentest does not change the published statement that a pentest is in every package. Source |
| TrustCloud | 7.5 | Insight Assurance, an audit firm, lists TrustCloud among its technology partners. This third-party record confirms (b) and lifts the cap, so the elements sum to 7.5. Source |
| Apptega | 7 | Apptega has an Audit Manager module with auditor collaboration and a partner directory of service providers that lists audits and pentests, with Prescient Security named. The directory is not a named audit-firm network, and a statement of audit or pentest billing was none found on 12 Nov 2026. Source |
| Delve | 7 | Delve sources and tracks the audit in Slack or the app, keeps a roster of audit firms, offers a free grey-box pentest, and marks audit cost 'Included in price'. All records are vendor-only, so the score is capped at 7. Source |
| Drata | 7 | Drata has an Audit Hub in all compliance plans and an Auditor Alliance of '175+ audit firms'. Vendr states auditor fees are separate, which Drata's pages do not state, and a pentest offer was none found on 12 Nov 2026. Source |
| Scytale | 7 | Scytale offers an Audit Management Hub, a directory of audit partner firms, and pen tests run with a pen test expert. A statement of what is included against billed separately was none found on 12 Nov 2026, and all records are vendor-only, so the score is capped at 7. Source |
| Sprinto | 7 | Sprinto docs describe an audit module and a network of accredited firms and CPAs, and list audit costs of '$1,000 and $25,000' without saying if the fee is in the subscription. Only pentest report upload was found, not a pentest service. Source |
| Strike Graph | 7 | Strike Graph gives auditors platform access and exports, has a partner network of independent auditors, and offers penetration testing services. A published statement of audit or pentest billing was none found on 12 Nov 2026, and all records are vendor-only, so the score is capped at 7. Source |
| Thoropass | 7 | Thoropass runs the audit in its platform through its own licensed CPA firm, sells pentesting as a separate service, and says its offer includes the auditor, which Vendr disputes. Every confirming record is from Thoropass or its own press releases, so the score is capped at 7. Source |
| Anecdotes | 6 | Anecdotes lets customers approve evidence and show auditors only ready controls, and lists audit partners including KPMG, Schellman and Coalfire. A pentest offer and a statement of audit billing were none found on 12 Nov 2026. Source |
| Hyperproof | 6 | Hyperproof has an audit workspace where auditors handle requests and a partner directory of audit firms such as A-LIGN and BDO. A pentest offer and a statement of audit or pentest billing were none found on 12 Nov 2026. Source |
| OneTrust | 6 | Insight Assurance, an audit firm, lists OneTrust among its technology partners. This third-party record supplies a partner audit firm (b), which was none found before. A pentest offer and a billing statement are still none found, so the total is 6. Source |
| Secureframe | 6 | Secureframe has an Audit Module for auditor access and evidence and a pricing row for its Audit Partner Network. A pentest offer and a statement of whether the audit is included were none found on 12 Nov 2026. Source |
| Comp AI | 4.5 | Comp AI offers AI-assisted pen test runs, says it is auditor-agnostic and mentions a 'fixed-fee auditor included' on one page. Its pages conflict on whether the audit and pentest are bundled, and an audit workspace was none found on 12 Nov 2026. Source |
Verdict by situation
- A startup that needs its first SOC 2 report this quarter: this criterion carries weight 25 of 100, and Scrut Automation, top on it at 9, is 4th overall at 6.28, while Oneleet leads at 6.85.
- A scaleup adding ISO 27001 and one more framework on top of SOC 2: this criterion carries weight 10 of 100, and Scrut Automation, top on it at 9, is 2nd overall at 7.78, while Secureframe leads at 8.10.
- A company in health or payments data that must hold HIPAA or PCI DSS as well: this criterion carries weight 15 of 100, and Scrut Automation, top on it at 9, is 2nd overall at 7.58, while Secureframe leads at 7.65.
- A lean security team with no compliance hire that wants the work done with it: this criterion carries weight 10 of 100, and Scrut Automation, top on it at 9, is 3rd overall at 6.88, while Scytale leads at 7.18.
- An enterprise replacing spreadsheets and a legacy GRC tool across many frameworks: this criterion carries weight 15 of 100, and Scrut Automation, top on it at 9, is 3rd overall at 7.43, while Secureframe leads at 8.00.
The other criteria
- Expert help included (weight 25)
- Automation depth (weight 20)
- AI that does the work under control (weight 15)
- After SOC 2 (weight 10)
- Pricing transparency (weight 10)
- Proof (weight 5)
Sources
- https://www.scrut.io/platform/audit-center, read 13 Nov 2026
- https://www.vanta.com/products/audit, read 13 Nov 2026
- https://www.oneleet.com/frameworks/soc-2, read 13 Nov 2026
- https://www.trustcloud.ai/soc2/, read 13 Nov 2026
- https://www.apptega.com/platform/audit-manager, read 13 Nov 2026
- https://delve.co/competitors, read 13 Nov 2026
- https://drata.com/products/compliance/audit-hub, read 13 Nov 2026
- https://scytale.ai/audit-management/, read 13 Nov 2026
- https://docs.sprinto.com/audits/overview.md, read 13 Nov 2026
- https://www.strikegraph.com/soc2, read 13 Nov 2026
- https://www.thoropass.com/solutions/audit-lifecycle-platform, read 13 Nov 2026
- https://www.anecdotes.ai/compliance, read 13 Nov 2026
- https://hyperproof.io/product/audit-management/, read 13 Nov 2026
- https://www.onetrust.com/solutions/soc-2-compliance/, read 13 Nov 2026
- https://support.secureframe.com/en/articles/15111410-collaborating-with-auditors-using-the-audit-module, read 13 Nov 2026
- https://www.trycomp.ai/, read 13 Nov 2026
Last reviewed 13 Nov 2026.